Displaying items by tag: Taylor Swift

Taylor Swift: A Marketing Machine That Overshadows Her Songwriting Brilliance

30 May, 2023

Taylor Swift. Love her or hate her, there's no escaping the relentless onslaught of her marketing machine. With every album release, she bombards her fans with an avalanche of merchandise, promotional stunts, and social media campaigns, leaving little room for her music to breathe. It's a shame because behind all the hype lies an artist with undeniable songwriting abilities.

Let's not mince words here. Taylor Swift knows how to write a damn good song. Her ability to capture the complexities of love, heartbreak, and personal growth with a razor-sharp wit is truly impressive. From the confessional narratives of "Love Story" to the biting introspection of "Blank Space," she has carved a niche for herself as a masterful storyteller. Swift's lyrical prowess is a force to be reckoned with, and her knack for creating catchy hooks is undeniable. She has the ability to pen hits that resonate with millions, and that's no small feat.

But here's the problem: Swift's relentless marketing machine overshadows her songwriting brilliance. It's as if the music itself has become a mere accessory to the larger spectacle she orchestrates. From the minute she announces a new album, the floodgates open, and her fans are bombarded with a barrage of merchandise, brand partnerships, and meticulously planned PR stunts. It's all about the image, the narrative, and the bottom line. 

In this era of social media dominance, Swift has perfected the art of self-promotion. Every move she makes is calculated to generate buzz and maintain her status as a pop culture icon. Whether it's teasing cryptic messages on Instagram or engaging in carefully crafted Twitter feuds, she has turned herself into a walking advertisement. The problem is, the music gets lost in the noise. Taylor Swift: The Brand is overwhelming the music.

One can't help but wonder if Swift's relentless marketing machine is a compensatory mechanism for the fear of being forgotten. With each album release, she seems to be desperately clinging to the spotlight, afraid that if she doesn't bombard her fans with constant reminders of her presence, they might move on to the next shiny object. It's an understandable fear in the fickle world of pop music, but it's also a disservice to her own artistry.

What we need from Taylor Swift is not more merchandise, extravagant music videos, or carefully orchestrated social media campaigns. We need her to strip away the layers of marketing and let the music speak for itself. We need her to embrace the vulnerability and authenticity that made her early work so compelling. We need her to trust in her songwriting abilities and let the songs breathe, rather than suffocating them under the weight of her marketing machine.

Taylor Swift is a talented songwriter, there's no doubt about it. But her relentless marketing tactics have become a distraction, overshadowing the very thing that made her a star in the first place. It's time for her to step back, take a deep breath, and remember that the true power of her music lies not in the merchandise or the promotional stunts, but in the raw emotion and storytelling she brings to the table. Only then can she reclaim her position as a true musical force, rather than just another product of the pop music marketing machine.

Have feedback or more information about this page? Email me at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Also, subscribe to my free, daily Too Much TV newsletter at toomuchtv.substack.com

Taylor Swift Fans Out To Remind Netflix That Only Taylor Swift Can Joke About How Many Men She May Or May Not Have Dated

01 March, 2021

One annoying aspect of writing about the world of entertainment is that there is no shortage of dumbass, over-blown controversies. Every day brings another story or two of some perceived slight or trumped up outrage and for the most part, I just tune it all out. Because even when the issue is legitimate (and half the time, it's really just some convoluted PR stunt), no one is going to give a crap about it 24 hours from now. And I am at the point in my life when I just don't have the desire to waste precious hours of my life dissecting someone's hurt feelings based on random tweets from fans.

Still, I decided to write about this latest Taylor Swift story because it's the perfect storm of brand management. fan overreaction and a not especially funny throwaway line in a streaming series. In a better world, this is the type of story that would never get past the Taylor Swift fan group text level. But it's 2021, and there is apparently no outrage too small to ignore. So even the Hollywood Trades wade in with a story or two, because....hey, pageviews.

This tale of misplaced PR assets begins with the new Netflix series Ginny And Georgia. There is a mention of singer Taylor Swift in episode ten and here is how it is described by TV Line:

Georgia (Brianne Howey) and daughter Ginny (Antonia Gentry) get into an argument, prompting the following comeback from Ginny when Georgia comments on her daughter’s relationship status: “What do you care? You go through men faster than Taylor Swift.”

It's a throwaway line and to be honest, it's not the greatest joke in the world. Especially since the young singer/global brand has apparently been in a committed relationship for several years. Still, it doesn't seem like a big deal. And when I watched the episode maybe six weeks ago before it premiered, the line didn't even register in my consciousness.

But apparently Taylor Swift noticed, because she did what any savvy celebrity does in 2021, she cranked out an angry tweet:

Hey Ginny & Georgia, 2010 called and it wants its lazy, deeply sexist joke back. How about we stop degrading hard working women by defining this horse shit as FuNnY. Also, @netflix after Miss Americana this outfit doesn’t look cute on you. Happy Women’s History Month I guess.

Now Swift is certainly entitled to be annoyed by the joke. But given that her PR people spent years encouraging fans to breathlessly dissect her songs for hints about her love life and her every dating move was indirectly monetized, the Ginny And Georgia line might be lazy, but it's not "deeply sexist." And it certainly doesn't rise to the level required to threaten Netflix with the "hey, I let you stream a special with me. How can you treat me this way?"

And in fact, the line seems to be there to be cringy and tone-deaf. It's a bit of a cheap shot on purpose, designed to show one of the nuanced aspects of the mother/daughter relationship and how people will say things in order to seem hip or cultural aware while at the same time also showing how out of touch they really are.

But regardless of any context for the line, Swift has a core sub-group of fans who love her in the same way that Zack Snyder fans love the #SnyderCut. So her fans swarmed onto sites such as IMDB, Metacritic and Rotten Tomatoes to downvote Ginny And Georgia. Because screw all of those people who worked on the show and the year or two of hard they put into the show. All I care about is a five-second not-that-funny joke in one episode. Fuck everything else, all that matters is the supposedly hurt feelings of my favorite singer.


What's the point of this piece? Part of it is just ranting, because I hate this entitled, whiney fan culture. As well as celebrities who engage in this passive, aggressive brand management and PR spin through social media outlets. I really enjoy Swift's music and I look forward to what she'll do in the next few decades. But while that throwaway line might not be a highlight of Ginny And Georgia, this overblown controversy isn't going to make any of Swift's "year-in-review" highlight reels.

Have a comment? Email me at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. or follow me on Twitter at @aysrick.